UPSC Mains
GS Paper II
Polity and Social Justice
Creamy Layer in OBC Reservation: Supreme Court Reaffirms Salary Rule
The Supreme Court reaffirmed its March 2026 judgment in Rohith Nathan, holding that an OBC candidate’s creamy layer status cannot be decided on the parents’ salary income alone
OBC RESERVATION
27%
OBC SHARE IN CENTRAL JOBS
26.3%
CREAMY LAYER CASE
Indra Sawhney (1992)
📰
Why in News
The Supreme Court reaffirmed its March 2026 judgment in Rohith Nathan. It held that an OBC candidate’s creamy layer status cannot be decided on the parents’ salary income alone.
The Court said it had not asked the government to reopen completed selections, as this could set government employees against one another.
📰
More on the News
- The 2004 clarification:
- The Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT) said that where the “equivalence” of posts in PSUs, banks and private jobs was not determined, salary income would count in the creamy layer test.
- From about 2015, the government used it to deny dozens of OBC candidates who had cleared the Civil Services Examination. Their parents’ salaries had crossed the threshold through pay revisions that did not reflect a change in occupational status.
- The March verdict: The Court rejected the use of the 2004 clarification to exclude candidates on parental salary alone.
- After the verdict: The government stalled service allocations following the 2025 examination, arguing that applying the ruling retrospectively would cause administrative chaos.
- Related data: The DoPT Annual Report 2024-25 puts OBC representation in central government jobs at 26.3%, falling steadily at higher levels.
⭐
Evolution of the Creamy Layer
- Indra Sawhney v. Union of India (1992): The Court upheld 27% OBC reservation in central services but required the exclusion of the creamy layer, meaning the socially and economically advanced among OBCs.
- 1993 DoPT office memorandum: It listed those in the creamy layer:
- Constitutional post holders.
- Group A and Group B officers of the Centre and States.
- PSU employees (through equivalence of posts).
- Armed Forces officers.
- Professionals, and persons in trade and industry.
- Property owners, and those who cross an income or wealth test.
- Salary and agriculture: The 1993 memorandum excluded income from salary and agricultural land from the income and wealth test.
- 2004 clarification: It brought salary back into the test for posts without determined equivalence.
- 2017: The Cabinet approved equivalence guidelines, which a parliamentary committee criticised on several points.
✅
Significance
- Fairness in selection: Candidates who cleared the examination are protected from losing benefits because of pay revisions that say little about real social advancement.
- Right test for advancement: Exclusion should rest on occupational status and wealth, not on a salary figure alone.
- Equality: Reservation under Articles 14 and 16(4) reaches those who need it only if exclusion criteria are applied consistently.
⚠️
Challenges
- Inconsistent rules: Equivalence of posts between government, PSU and private jobs has stayed unsettled for decades.
- Administrative disruption: Reopening completed selections may displace people already allocated services.
- Unequal benefits within OBCs: The Rohini Commission report on sub-categorisation, submitted in 2023, is still not public.
- Data gaps: There is little data on the education, occupations, assets and landholdings of each caste.
- Access to remedies: Only those who can afford litigation are likely to get relief.
📌
Prelims Pointers
- Creamy layer was introduced by Indra Sawhney v. Union of India (1992), also called the Mandal Commission case.
- The same case upheld 27% OBC reservation and capped total reservation at 50%.
- The Mandal Commission (Second Backward Classes Commission) was set up in 1979 under B. P. Mandal.
- The Rohini Commission was constituted under Article 340 to examine sub-categorisation of OBCs.
- Article 16(4): reservation in public employment for backward classes not adequately represented. Article 15(4): special provisions for backward classes in education.
- The National Commission for Backward Classes (NCBC) is a constitutional body under Article 338B (102nd Amendment, 2018).
🛤️
Way Forward
Frame clear equivalence rules for PSU, bank and private sector posts, and apply the 1993 rules uniformly.
Create supernumerary posts for legitimate claimants, so that no one is displaced and relief does not depend on going to court.
Make the Rohini Commission report public and use it for sub-categorisation.
Use caste enumeration in the Census, along with socio-economic data, to review the creamy layer limits.
Conclusion: Excluding the creamy layer keeps reservation focused on those who still face disadvantage. This works only if the criteria are fair, consistent and backed by good data, so that no deserving candidate is denied by an arbitrary salary test.
📰
Source: The Hindu, The Indian Express

