UPSC Mains
GS Paper II
Polity and Governance
Police Encounters and the Rule of Law
A man accused of raping and murdering a minor girl was killed in a police encounter in Uttar Dinajpur, West Bengal, the fourth such incident in the State since May, reviving debate on whether encounters are replacing due process
UP ENCOUNTER OPERATIONS
17,043 (2017–2026)
PUNJAB, NOV 2025 – JAN 2026
34 encounters
KEY CASE
PUCL (2014)
📰
Why in News
A man accused of raping and murdering a minor girl was killed in a police encounter in Uttar Dinajpur, West Bengal. It was the fourth such incident in the State since May.
The incident has revived debate on whether “encounters” are becoming routine and are replacing due process.
📰
More on the News
- Not an isolated trend: Similar incidents are reported across States.
- Andhra Pradesh (Anantapur): A 21-year-old accused of attacking a schoolgirl was shot by police and later had his leg amputated.
- Uttar Pradesh: Official data records 17,043 police encounter operations between March 2017 and May 2026.
- Punjab: A newspaper investigation found 34 encounters between November 2025 and January 2026, more than one every three days.
- Public approval: Leaders often present “instant justice” as proof of resolve against crime, which can win public support.
- Past case: The 2019 Hyderabad rape-murder case, in which the four accused were killed in an alleged encounter, is cited as a precedent that drew wide public approval.
⭐
Legal Position
- PUCL v. State of Maharashtra (2014): The Supreme Court laid down safeguards for police encounters that cause death:
- Mandatory registration of an FIR.
- An independent investigation.
- A magisterial inquiry.
- Arif Md Yeasin Jwadder v. State of Assam (May 2025): The Court reaffirmed that these safeguards are binding and cannot depend on the victim or the family starting proceedings.
- Constitutional basis: Encounter killings raise issues under Article 21 (life and personal liberty) and Article 14 (equality before law and due process).
- Use of force in arrest: Under criminal procedure law (now Section 43 of the BNSS, 2023), police may cause death during arrest only when the offence is punishable with death or life imprisonment and the person resists.
✅
Significance
- Rule of law: The legitimacy of criminal justice rests on the certainty, fairness and credibility of due process, not on the speed or spectacle of punishment.
- Institutional credibility: Political gain from “toughness” comes at the cost of trust in the police and courts.
- Citizens’ freedoms: Weak accountability creates a cycle that shrinks civil liberties.
⚠️
Challenges
- Weak compliance: Courts have drawn clear lines, but the safeguards depend on institutional compliance.
- Public sentiment: Anger over brutal crimes creates pressure for quick punishment.
- Slow justice delivery: Long investigations and trials make shortcuts appear attractive.
- Police as a State subject: Police and public order are State subjects, so practices differ across States.
- Lack of independent probe: Investigations of encounters are often carried out by the same police force.
📌
Prelims Pointers
- Police and public order are in the State List (Seventh Schedule).
- Article 21: no person shall be deprived of life or personal liberty except by procedure established by law.
- NHRC: a statutory body set up under the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993. It has issued guidelines requiring that encounter deaths be reported to it.
- Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023 replaced the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
- PUCL v. State of Maharashtra (2014) is the key case on investigating police encounters.
🛤️
Way Forward
Enforce the PUCL guidelines strictly, with independent investigation and prompt magisterial inquiry in every case.
Report every encounter death to the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) and the court, and publish State-wise data.
Fix personal accountability of officers where an encounter is found to be unjustified, and provide compensation to families.
Strengthen investigation and prosecution, including forensic capacity, so that fair trials deliver results quickly.
Conclusion: Decisive policing is needed, but it must act within the law. The safeguards laid down by the Supreme Court are the conditions of a fair system, and enforcing them is the surest way to uphold both public safety and the rule of law.
📰
Source: The Indian Express

