🎯 Dronacharya Mentorship 2026–27 batch now open — limited seats. Ask on WhatsApp →

Electoral Rolls and Welfare Targeting: Voter ID Versus Aadhaar

UPSC Mains GS Paper II Polity and Governance

Electoral Rolls and Welfare Targeting: Voter ID Versus Aadhaar

The Union Panchayati Raj Ministry has indicated that voter identity cards (EPIC) with biometric authentication will replace Aadhaar for identifying beneficiaries and making payments under its schemes
VOTING AGE
18 (61st Amendment, 1988)
AADHAAR FOR WELFARE
Section 7, Aadhaar Act
KEY JUDGMENT
Puttaswamy (2018)
📰

Why in News

The Union Panchayati Raj Ministry has indicated that voter identity cards (EPIC) with biometric authentication will replace Aadhaar for identifying beneficiaries and making payments under its schemes.

This raises questions in light of the Supreme Court’s view that the electoral roll serves electoral purposes alone.

⭐

Electoral Roll Versus Aadhaar

  • Purpose of the roll: It lists persons eligible to vote, under Article 326 (adult suffrage) and the Representation of the People Act, 1950.
  • Not every citizen is a voter: Children below 18 and those not enrolled are outside the roll, but may still need welfare.
  • Purpose of Aadhaar: A 12-digit identity number issued by the UIDAI for identification and delivery of subsidies and benefits (Section 7, Aadhaar Act, 2016).
  • Aadhaar is not proof of citizenship: It shows identity and residence, not nationality or voting eligibility.
  • Legal position: In Puttaswamy (Aadhaar), 2018, the Supreme Court upheld Aadhaar for welfare benefits and PAN linking, but restricted its mandatory use for bank accounts, mobile numbers and school admissions.
✅

Significance

  • Right to welfare: Linking benefits to the roll can exclude eligible persons, since welfare is tied to need and not to voting status.
  • Institutional limits: It keeps the ECI’s work confined to electoral purposes.
  • Legal clarity: Welfare identification rests on statutory frameworks such as the Aadhaar Act, not on a roll maintained for elections.
⚠️

Challenges

  • Exclusion risk: Wrongful deletions or errors in the roll would cut off benefits.
  • Dual burden: Persons struck off the roll may lose both vote and welfare.
  • Data and privacy: Reusing biometric and electoral data raises purpose limitation and privacy concerns (Article 21).
  • Migrants: Itinerant workers find it harder to prove residence.
  • Authentication failures: Biometric mismatches already affect Aadhaar-based payments.
📌

Prelims Pointers

  • EPIC: Electors’ Photo Identity Card, issued by the ECI.
  • ECI: A constitutional body under Article 324.
  • Article 326: Elections to the Lok Sabha and Assemblies are on the basis of adult suffrage. The voting age is 18 (61st Amendment, 1988).
  • Aadhaar: Issued by the UIDAI, a statutory authority under the Aadhaar Act, 2016. Section 7 allows its use for subsidies and benefits.
  • Puttaswamy (2018): Upheld Aadhaar for welfare, with limits on private use.
🛤️

Way Forward

Keep the electoral roll for electoral purposes and welfare identification under a clear statutory basis.
Allow alternative documents and avoid denying benefits on a single ID.
Ensure due process, notice and appeal before any deletion.
Strengthen data protection under the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023.
Seek an early Supreme Court decision on the pending SIR challenges.
Conclusion: A voter list decides who can vote, and welfare should reach everyone who needs it. Keeping the two systems separate protects both the right to vote and the right to benefits.
📰
Source: The Hindu

This will close in 0 seconds

Scroll to Top