🎯 Dronacharya Mentorship 2026–27 batch now open — limited seats. Ask on WhatsApp →

Case for Splitting the Supreme Court: Constitutional Court and Regional Appeal Courts

UPSC Mains GS Paper II Polity and Governance

Case for Splitting the Supreme Court: Constitutional Court and Regional Appeal Courts

A proposal has been put forward to split the Supreme Court into a small Constitutional Court and regional Courts of Appeal, as pendency crossed 92,000 cases
PENDING CASES (END-2025)
92,318
CONSTITUTION BENCH RULINGS
~134 a year (1960s) to under 10
PROPOSED MODEL
11-judge Court + 4 to 5 Appeal Courts
📰

Why in News

A proposal has been put forward to split the Supreme Court into a small Constitutional Court and regional Courts of Appeal, as pendency crossed 92,000 cases.

A 2016 reference by a three-judge Bench on this question remains unheard by a larger Bench.

📊

More on the News

  • Backlog: The Court had 92,318 pending cases at the end of 2025, its highest ever. Fresh filings (75,410) outran disposals (65,615), even after its strength rose to 38 judges.
  • Drift from its constitutional role: Constitution Bench decisions fell from about 134 a year in the early 1960s to fewer than 10 in the last decade, as Article 136 appeals filled the docket.
  • Proposed model: A Constitutional Court of about 11 judges in Delhi, with four or five regional Courts of Appeal for ordinary appeals. The 229th Law Commission Report (2009) and a Parliamentary Standing Committee (2023) backed similar ideas.
🌍

Lessons from Other Systems

CountryModel
United StatesThe Supreme Court sits above 13 federal Courts of Appeals and reviews only about 1% of the roughly 7,000 petitions a year.
South AfricaA Constitutional Court (Johannesburg) and a separate Supreme Court of Appeal (Bloemfontein).
GermanyThe Federal Constitutional Court (Karlsruhe) hears constitutional matters alone.
BrazilThe 1988 Constitution created a separate appellate court. Backlog fell only after the apex court got power to filter cases (the “general repercussion” test, 2004). So a split needs a filter too.
🗣️

The Main Objection

Some have argued that a divided Court would no longer be one supreme Court, and regional courts may be seen as lesser venues.

Supporters reply that the Court is already divided by volume into many small Benches, and that the constitutional core is being lost.

✅

Significance

  • Constitutional role restored: A dedicated Bench can sit in full strength and settle questions once.
  • Speedier justice: Regional courts can clear ordinary appeals faster and bring justice closer to litigants.
  • Consistency: Fewer conflicting rulings from scattered Benches.
⚠️

Challenges

  • Fear of diluting the Court’s unity and authority.
  • Litigants may still press to reach Delhi.
  • Without a case filter, the new court could face the same congestion.
  • Constitutional and political consensus may be needed, if an amendment is required.
📌

Prelims Pointers

  • Article 124: Establishment and constitution of the Supreme Court.
  • Article 130: Seat of the Supreme Court is Delhi, or other places appointed by the Chief Justice of India with the President’s approval.
  • Article 136: Special leave to appeal, a discretionary power.
  • Article 145(3): At least five judges to decide a substantial question of constitutional law.
  • Law Commission of India: A non-statutory, executive body, constituted by the Government for fixed terms.
🛤️

Way Forward

Hear the 2016 reference early through a larger Bench.
Consider regional Benches under Article 130 as a first step.
Introduce a filter for admitting cases, and limit routine SLPs.
Strengthen High Courts, tribunals and alternative dispute resolution to cut appeals.
Build consensus among the Bar, Bench and Parliament.
Conclusion: A Supreme Court that decides fewer cases with greater care can better guard the Constitution. Any reform should protect the Court’s authority and ensure that the people get timely justice.
📰
Source: The Hindu

This will close in 0 seconds

Scroll to Top