UPSC Mains
GS Paper II
Polity and Governance
Death Penalty: India’s Vote Against a UN Moratorium and Questions on Safeguards
India voted against a proposed UN moratorium on the death penalty, reviving the debate on whether the safeguards around capital punishment in India actually work
DEATH ROW (31 DEC 2025)
574 prisoners
RELEASED FROM DEATH ROW (2016–2025)
38 persons
BACHAN SINGH, 1980
“Rarest of rare”
📰
Why in News
India voted against a proposed global moratorium on the death penalty at the UN. This is consistent with its past stand.
The vote has revived the debate on whether the safeguards around capital punishment in India actually work.
📊
More on the News
- India’s stand: Retaining the death penalty is a sovereign decision, backed by safeguards such as the “rarest of rare” rule and High Court confirmation of death sentences.
- Supreme Court: It has increasingly restricted capital punishment. Research shows no extra deterrence compared with life imprisonment.
- Last executions: In 2020, in the Delhi gang-rape and murder case.
- Expanded offences: Parliament has added more capital offences under the BNS, which the article calls penal populism.
- Death row: 574 prisoners on 31 December 2025, the highest since 2016.
❓
Why the Safeguards Are Questioned
- Trial court sentences: Most death sentences come from trial courts, and many are later overturned.
- Releases: The Supreme Court released 38 persons from death row between 2016 and 2025, after an average of eight years there. Some had spent more than two decades.
- Flawed evidence: Safeguards do not stop convictions based on weak evidence or false testimony.
- Unequal legal help: Access to competent lawyers differs among those facing the penalty.
- Law Commission (2015): It said the death penalty “fails to achieve any constitutionally valid penological goal” and recommended abolishing it for all crimes except terrorism and waging war.
⭐
Legal Framework
- Bachan Singh (1980): The Supreme Court upheld the death penalty but limited it to the “rarest of rare” cases.
- Confirmation: A death sentence by a sessions court must be confirmed by the High Court.
- Mercy powers: The President (Article 72) and Governors (Article 161) can grant clemency.
- Delay: In Shatrughan Chauhan (2014), the Court held that unexplained delay in deciding a mercy petition can be a ground to commute the sentence.
- UN position: The UN General Assembly has passed resolutions calling for a moratorium on executions since 2007. India has voted against them.
📌
Prelims Pointers
- Article 21: Right to life, which the death penalty must satisfy through fair procedure.
- Article 72 and 161: Clemency powers of the President and Governors.
- Project 39A: A project of the National Law University, Delhi, that studies the death penalty in India.
🛤️
Suggested Reforms
Suspend executions and review the penalty laws and the treatment of prisoners on death row.
Remove the penalty for offences that do not involve intentional killing. Excessively harsh punishment for non-fatal crimes can push offenders to escalate violence, even to killing witnesses.
Abolish it in law over time, while improving investigation, prosecution and legal aid.
Conclusion: A punishment that cannot be undone needs a justice system that does not make mistakes. Since India’s system cannot guarantee this, the focus should be on fair investigation, legal aid and a gradual move away from the death penalty.
📰
Source: The Hindu

