UPSC Mains
GS Paper II
Governance
Beed Drought and Rural Employment Guarantee: From MGNREGA to VB-G RAM G
Maharashtra is facing one of its worst droughts, and rural women in Beed allege they are being denied work under the employment guarantee scheme, now replaced by VB-G RAM G
APPLICATIONS FILED (ONE VILLAGE)
175, only 8 got work
NEW RURAL WAGE BENCHMARK
₹300 a day
WORKS STALLED
4 wells awaiting approval
📰
Why in News
Maharashtra is facing one of its worst droughts, with Beed among the worst-hit districts.
Rural women allege that they are being denied work under the employment guarantee scheme, which has now been replaced by VB-G RAM G.
📊
What Is Happening in Beed?
- Crop failure: Cotton plants are stunted and bolls are missing, so families have little to pick or sell.
- Migration: Beed sees heavy seasonal migration for sugarcane cutting, which has begun earlier this year.
- Work denied: In one village of about 15,000 people, women filed 175 applications for work earlier this year, and only eight got work, according to them.
- Pending applications: The panchayat says it received 40 applications under VB-G RAM G, while villagers say hundreds are pending.
- Stalled works: Work on four wells was stopped as there was no approval under VB-G RAM G, according to the panchayat.
🔄
What Has Changed from MGNREGA to VB-G RAM G?
- Replacement: MGNREGA, 2005 has been replaced by VB-G RAM G (Viksit Bharat – Guarantee for Rozgar and Ajeevika Mission (Gramin)).
- Common aim: Both give legal, guaranteed wage employment to rural households to reduce poverty and ensure livelihood security.
- Wage benchmark: ₹300 a day is the new national benchmark for rural wages under VB-G RAM G.
- Transition issue: Approvals and instructions for works under the new framework have been slow at the village level.
🌵
Why Does the Delay Matter in a Drought?
- Income loss: Without farm work, wage employment is the main fallback for landless labourers and small farmers.
- Distress migration: Denied work pushes families to migrate, which disrupts children’s education and health care.
- Gender impact: Women depend heavily on local work and face greater hardship when it is not available.
- Asset creation: Delays also stop water-conservation works (wells, farm ponds) that would reduce future drought impact.
✅
Significance
- Social safety net: Rural employment guarantees are the main income support during drought.
- Rights-based design: Employment under the scheme is a demand-driven entitlement, so non-delivery is a governance failure.
- Drought resilience: Works such as water conservation link relief with long-term resilience.
⚠️
Challenges
- Implementation gaps: Unwillingness or delay at the panchayat level, and unclear instructions from the district.
- Transition risks: Shifting from one scheme to another can interrupt approvals, job cards and funds.
- Awareness and access: Workers often get no acknowledgement or information on applications.
- Accountability: Weak social audits and grievance redress.
- Climate stress: Repeated droughts in the same districts raise relief needs every year.
🛤️
Way Forward
Special drought works: Start works at once in affected talukas and keep the panchayat office accessible.
Transparent records: Give a dated receipt for every application and publish pending demands.
Time-bound action: Provide work within the legal time limit or give an unemployment allowance.
Social audit: Strengthen gram sabha reviews and grievance redress.
Water security: Focus works on watershed development and groundwater recharge.
Alternative cropping: Support drought-tolerant crops and crop insurance.
Conclusion: A guarantee is only as strong as its delivery at the village level. In a drought, timely work and transparent records can protect families from distress migration.
📰
Source: The Hindu

