UPSC Mains
GS Paper II
Polity
DPDP Act, 2023 and Press Freedom: Where Should the Line Be Drawn?
A digital news publishers’ association has asked the Supreme Court for an interim stay on provisions of the DPDP Act, 2023, saying the law threatens press freedom
LAW UNDER CHALLENGE
DPDP Act, 2023
PRIVACY AS A FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT
Puttaswamy, 2017
PRESS FREEDOM
Article 19(1)(a)
📰
Why in News
A digital news publishers’ association has asked the Supreme Court for an interim stay on provisions of the Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Act, 2023, saying the law threatens press freedom.
The case raises the question of how to balance privacy (Article 21) with freedom of the press (Article 19(1)(a)).
⚖️
How Have Courts Balanced Privacy and Press Freedom?
Rights in tension: investigation versus a private life.
- Constitutional base: The press freedom to investigate comes from Article 19(1)(a). The Right to Privacy is a Fundamental Right under Article 21, as held in K.S. Puttaswamy (2017).
- R. Rajagopal v. State of Tamil Nadu (1994): A public official cannot claim privacy to stop scrutiny of acts done in an official capacity. But holding office does not open up every part of private life. The Court also held that the State cannot impose prior restraint on publication on privacy grounds.
- Sahara India Real Estate Corp. v. SEBI (2012): Investigative journalism and open justice are vital, but courts can postpone reporting if publicity poses a real and substantial risk to a fair trial.
- Manu Sharma v. State (NCT of Delhi) (2010): The Court warned against media trials that turn an accused into a convict before the verdict.
🎥
Can Sting Operations Be Justified?
Where does investigation end and entrapment begin?
- R.K. Anand v. Registrar, Delhi High Court (2009): The Court upheld a sting that exposed an attempt to suborn a court witness, as it served an important public cause.
- Rajat Prasad v. CBI (2014): Investigative journalism has public-interest value, but gives no blanket immunity for unlawful acts during a sting. Criminal intent and role must be proved on evidence.
- Takeaway: A claim of public interest does not by itself erase criminal liability.
🌍
How Do Other Countries Balance the Two?
- International law: Articles 17 and 19 of the ICCPR and Articles 8 and 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights protect both privacy and expression.
- Axel Springer v. Germany (2012): The European Court of Human Rights ruled (12 to 5) that restrictions on a newspaper’s report on an actor’s arrest violated press freedom, since the press acts as a watchdog on matters of public interest.
- USA: The First Amendment (1791) protects the press. The Privacy Protection Act, 1980 restricts searches and seizures of journalists’ unpublished work, with exceptions.
- UK: The Data Protection Act, 2018 allows a journalism exemption if publication is reasonably believed to be in the public interest.
- Brazil: Its General Data Protection Law excludes data processing for journalistic purposes.
- Kenya: Section 52 of its Data Protection Act, 2019 gives a conditional exemption for journalism.
✅
Significance
- Constitutional balance: Tests how two Fundamental Rights, privacy and free expression, can coexist.
- Public’s right to know: Investigative journalism supports accountability and transparency.
- Data governance: Shows how a general data protection law meets a sector that depends on using personal information.
⚠️
Challenges
- No express exemption: The Act does not give journalism a clear exemption, which critics say leaves room for chilling effect.
- Consent model: Consent from subjects is unworkable for investigative reporting on wrongdoing.
- Source protection: Compelled disclosure risks exposing whistleblowers.
- Misuse risk: A very wide exemption could be used to publish private information with no public-interest basis.
- Court-made line: Standards on public interest and privacy come from case law, not clear statute.
🛤️
Way Forward
Targeted exemption: Provide a conditional journalistic exemption, tied to public interest and ethical standards, as in the UK and Kenya models.
Safeguards: Keep protections against harm to private life and trial fairness.
Clear tests: Define public interest, proportionality and source protection in rules or guidelines.
Self-regulation: Strengthen press and digital media ethics codes and grievance bodies.
Judicial guidance: Use the Court’s pending hearing to set out balancing principles.
Conclusion: Privacy and press freedom are both essential to a democracy. A clear, conditional exemption for public-interest journalism can protect both the individual and the public’s right to know.
📰
Source: The Hindu

